Special Hours: From November 21 to 28 we’ll be opening at 11am

Last Updated: November 12, 2026

On This Page

 

A Margherita pizza is a classic Italian pie topped with tomato, mozzarella, and basil. The topping list stays short on purpose, so you taste the sauce, the cheese, and the crust instead of a pile of extras. At Brooklyn Pizza in Boulder, you will find it on the menu as the Pizza Margarita, in small and large.

If you have ever looked at a pizza menu and wondered whether a Margherita is just a cheese pizza with a fancier name, you are in good company. Below is what the pizza is, how it differs from a plain cheese pie, and how to order the Margarita at Brooklyn Pizza.

Brooklyn Pizza Boulder blog graphic showing a Margherita pizza topped with fresh basil leaves, with the title What kind of pizza is a Margherita pizza in Boulder, CO

Margherita vs. Cheese Pizza

A plain cheese pizza is sauce and cheese, with no rule about which cheese. A Margherita adds fresh basil leaves and is usually made with fresh mozzarella, according to Chowhound. Both are meat-free and cheese-forward, which is why people mix them up.

Brooklyn Pizza sells both. On the menu, a Cheese Pizza is $17 small and $22 large. The Pizza Margarita is $19.50 small and $25.50 large, so it runs $2.50 more in the small and $3.50 more in the large.

If you want the classic with a little more character, that gap is small. If you want the most familiar slice, the cheese pizza is right there.

Three Ingredients, Three Colors

A Margherita is built on three things: tomato, mozzarella, and basil. They also happen to be red, white, and green, the colors of the Italian flag. National Geographic calls it an iconic Neapolitan dish whose ingredients make up those flag colors.

With so few ingredients, nothing can hide. A good crust, a bright sauce, and cheese that melts the right way do all the work. Sausage, pepperoni, and piles of vegetables belong on other pizzas.

The Pizza Margarita at Brooklyn Pizza

At Brooklyn Pizza, the Margherita style is listed as Pizza Margarita, spelled without the h. It comes in a small at $19.50 and a large at $25.50. There is also a Pizza Margarita with Arugula, at $20.50 small and $27.50 large, which the homepage names as one of the specialty pizzas.

The menu does not spell out the toppings on each pizza, so if you want to know exactly how the shop builds its Margarita, ask when you order. The menu’s topping list includes basil, fresh mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, and garlic, so it is also worth asking what you can add.

Brooklyn Pizza makes its pizza dough from scratch, and its About page calls the pizza New York style. If you are curious what that means, our guide to New York style pizza in Boulder explains it. To see how the Margarita stacks up against the rest of the lineup, read our picks for the top pizzas in Boulder.

For a side, the menu has an Arugula Parmesan salad at $6 small and $8 large. Check the full menu for everything else.

How to Order a Pizza Margarita in Boulder

Ordering is simple. Order online for pickup, or call 720-328-2324 and collect your pizza at 1647 Arapahoe Ave. in Boulder. The shop is open Monday through Thursday from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m., Friday from 10 a.m. to midnight, and Saturday from 11 a.m. to midnight. It is closed on Sundays.

Not sure what to pair it with? Our guide to which pizza is best to order online in Boulder walks through the menu by craving, and our local guide to the best pizza in Boulder shows where the Margarita fits in.

Slice or Whole Pie

Brooklyn Pizza serves pizza by the slice as well as by the pie. What sits on the counter changes through the day, so call ahead to ask whether a Margarita slice is out. Ordering a whole pie for a group? See how many slices come in a large pizza in our slice guide.

Where the Name Comes From

The popular story says a Naples pizza maker named Raffaele Esposito made a tomato, mozzarella, and basil pizza for Queen Margherita of Italy during her 1889 visit, and named it after her. National Geographic says parts of that story have been verified.

But it also points to an 1853 collection of essays on Neapolitan customs that describes a pizza topped with basil, mozzarella, and tomatoes, at least three decades before any royal visit. Whatever the truth, the name stuck. Today, ordering a Margherita simply tells the kitchen you want the simple, classic pie.

Frequently Asked Questions

What kind of pizza is a Margherita pizza?

A Margherita is a classic Italian pizza topped with tomato, mozzarella, and basil. Those three ingredients match the red, white, and green of the Italian flag.

Is a Margherita pizza the same as a cheese pizza?

Not exactly. Both are cheese-forward, but a Margherita adds fresh basil and is usually made with fresh mozzarella, while a plain cheese pizza has no set recipe. Brooklyn Pizza lists both on its menu.

Why does the Brooklyn Pizza menu say Margarita?

The menu lists the pizza as Pizza Margarita. If you are looking for a Margherita, that is the menu item to ask about, and the team can tell you how they make it.

How much is the Pizza Margarita at Brooklyn Pizza?

The menu lists the Pizza Margarita at $19.50 for a small and $25.50 for a large. The Pizza Margarita with Arugula is $20.50 small and $27.50 large. Check the menu page for current prices.

Can I get a Margarita pizza by the slice?

Brooklyn Pizza serves pizza by the slice and by the pie. The slices on the counter vary, so call ahead if you want a Margarita slice specifically.

How do I order a Margarita pizza in Boulder?

You can order online for pickup or call the shop and pick it up at 1647 Arapahoe Ave. Ordering ahead on busy Friday and Saturday nights helps your order be ready when you want it.