Last Updated: November 5, 2026
In this guide:
- Why Boulder Has No Single Best Pizza
- Five Things That Make a Pizza Worth Remembering
- How We Make Ours at Brooklyn Pizza
- Match the Pizza to the Moment
- A Three-Bite Test You Can Run Anywhere
- Plan Your Visit
- Frequently Asked Questions
The best pizza in Boulder, CO depends on the style you want: wood-fired Neapolitan for a sit-down dinner, taphouse pies for a big group, and New York-style for a large, foldable, crisp-edged slice. For New York-style, Brooklyn Pizza at 1647 Arapahoe Ave. has made its dough from scratch and its mozzarella in-house since 2015.
Ask ten people in Boulder where to find the best pizza and you will get ten different answers. Most of them will be right, because “best” depends on what you want from the pizza on that particular night.
We should be upfront: we run Brooklyn Pizza Boulder, so we have a favorite. This guide still tries to be useful to anyone hunting for a great pie, whether they end up at our counter or somewhere else. Here is how to judge Boulder pizza and match it to your mood.
Why Boulder Has No Single Best Pizza
Boulder supports several real pizza traditions side by side. There are wood-fired Neapolitan restaurants, craft beer pizza houses, and counters that sell New York-style pies and slices. They are different foods that happen to share a name, and knowing the difference keeps you from ordering the wrong pizza for the occasion.
A Neapolitan pie bakes for roughly a minute or two in a wood-burning oven. It comes out soft and blistered in the middle, and it is usually eaten with a knife and fork. Pizzeria Alberico on Pearl Street, which took over from Pizzeria Locale, and Basta, which opened in 2010 with a single wood-fired oven, both work in this tradition and have loyal followings.
A New York pie bakes longer at a lower temperature. The bottom turns crisp, the edge stays chewy, and the slices are wide enough to fold in one hand while you walk. Neither style wins. Asking which is better is like asking whether a steakhouse beats a great deli. It depends on the craving.
Five Things That Make a Pizza Worth Remembering
Whatever style you prefer, these five details separate a forgettable pie from one you talk about the next day.
- The crust. Good dough has flavor of its own. Scratch-made dough with quality flour tastes noticeably different from a frozen base, and you can feel the difference in the chew.
- The cheese. Mozzarella should taste creamy and a little sweet, with no rubbery bite. Whole-milk mozzarella melts into an even layer and browns in small spots.
- The sauce. Sauce is a supporting actor. It should taste bright and tomato-forward without burying the cheese.
- The toppings. Fresh vegetables taste like vegetables. Canned or frozen ones turn watery in the oven and leave a soggy slice.
- The consistency. Anyone can make one great pie. The real test is whether the pizza tastes the same on a quiet Tuesday and a packed Friday.
How We Make Ours at Brooklyn Pizza

We opened on Arapahoe Ave. in 2015, and the story behind Brooklyn Pizza is simple: make New York-style pizza the way it should be made, with no shortcuts you can taste. Our dough is made from scratch with premium flour. Our whole-milk mozzarella is made in-house and goes on every pie except the vegan one. Vegetables are delivered three times a week, and we never use canned or frozen ones.
That list lines up with the five points above on purpose. We think the best pizza in Boulder is the one that gets the basics right every single day, and we cook to that standard.
The menu covers the classics and a few Italian favorites. A plain cheese pie starts at $17 for a small and $22 for a large. Pepperoni, Four Cheese, and Pizza Margarita are there for traditionalists. If you want a shortlist, see our top three pizzas in Boulder. If you want something with more edge, try the Italian Sausage and Rabe, the Prosciutto and Arugula, or the Margarita with Arugula. Past the pizza, the kitchen turns out homemade lasagna with fresh pasta, a handful of salads, and freshly made cannolis. The topping list runs past 25 options, from fresh mozzarella and ricotta to capers and anchovies.
We also sell pizza by the slice as well as by the pie, so a quick lunch for one and a family dinner for six both work. To size a group order, see how many slices are in a large pizza.
Match the Pizza to the Moment
Here is a quick way to choose, based on what you actually need from the meal.
| The Moment | Style to Look For | Why It Fits |
|---|---|---|
| Fast lunch between meetings | New York-style slice | A wide slice comes out hot and travels well |
| Slow date-night dinner | Wood-fired Neapolitan | Smaller, softer pies are made for a knife, fork, and a long conversation |
| A big group with a taste for beer | Taphouse pizza | Large menus and big tables keep everyone happy |
| Family dinner at home | New York-style pie, large | It reheats well and feeds a crowd |
| A vegan guest at the table | A kitchen with a dedicated vegan pie | Real options beat a pizza with the cheese removed |
That last row matters more than people expect. Our vegan pizza skips the house mozzarella, and vegan cheese is available on it. If you have allergies or other dietary restrictions, tell us when you order and we will work with you.
A Three-Bite Test You Can Run Anywhere

You do not need a food critic’s palate to judge pizza. Order a plain cheese pie first, because there is nowhere for a weak kitchen to hide, and then run this test.
- Bite one, the edge. It should have some chew and a little char, with a crust that tastes like baked bread.
- Bite two, the center. The cheese and sauce should sit in balance, with no puddle of grease or watery tomato.
- Bite three, the fold. A New York slice should bend without cracking or flopping. If the tip drops, the dough was underbaked or too wet.
Do the same test at every pizzeria on your list. After a few visits you will have your own answer, and it will beat any ranking you read online, including this one.
Plan Your Visit
You will find us at 1647 Arapahoe Ave., Boulder, CO 80302. We are open Monday through Thursday from 10am to 10pm, Friday from 10am to midnight, and Saturday from 11am to midnight. We are closed on Sundays. Ordering ahead is the easiest way to skip the wait, and the online order page is set up for pickup. For picks that travel well, see which pizza is best to order online. You can also stop in. Exploring the area? See where locals eat in Boulder. Hosting a party? We cater orders of 10 or more pizzas with advance notice.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza in Boulder, CO?
There is no single answer because Boulder has several strong styles. Wood-fired Neapolitan suits a sit-down dinner, taphouse pizza suits big groups, and New York-style suits anyone who wants a large, foldable slice. Brooklyn Pizza Boulder makes New York-style pizza with scratch-made dough and in-house mozzarella.
Is there New York-style pizza in Boulder?
Yes. Brooklyn Pizza at 1647 Arapahoe Ave. has served New York-style pizza by the slice and by the pie since 2015. It also offers pasta, salads, and cannolis.
What is the difference between New York-style and Neapolitan pizza?
Neapolitan pizza bakes quickly in a very hot wood-fired oven and comes out soft and blistered in the middle. New York-style pizza bakes longer at a lower heat, which gives a crisp bottom, a chewy edge, and large slices you can fold.
Does Brooklyn Pizza Boulder have vegan pizza?
Yes. We offer a vegan pizza, and vegan cheese is available for it. We also accommodate dietary restrictions and allergies when you let us know at the time of your order.
Can I order Brooklyn Pizza for pickup in Boulder?
Yes. You can order online for pickup, or stop in. The best way to confirm your pickup timing is to ask when you order.
Can I order catering for a party?
Yes. We cater orders of 10 or more pizzas with advance notice. Contact us as early as you can so we can plan the timing for your event.
Come Taste a Real New York Slice in Boulder
Skip the guesswork and test our pizza yourself. Order online for pickup, send us a message with questions about catering or dietary needs, or call us at 720-328-2324.