Last Updated: November 9, 2026
In this guide:
- How We Picked These Three
- Pepperoni, the New York Classic
- Pizza Margarita, Simple Done Right
- Pizza Puttanesca, for the Bold Palate
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What the Top Pizzas Have in Common
- Prefer to Build Your Own?
- How to Order in Boulder
If you are deciding what to order in Boulder, three Brooklyn Pizza pies are easy to put at the top of your list: the Pepperoni, the Pizza Margarita, and the Pizza Puttanesca. They are built on the same scratch-made dough and in-house whole-milk mozzarella, yet each one answers a different craving, from familiar and comforting to fresh and herb-forward to bold and briny. You can order any of them as a 12-inch small or a 16-inch large for pickup, or phone in your order.
Ask ten people in Boulder to name the best pizza in town, and you will get ten different answers, because “best” almost always comes down to what you are in the mood for. A craving for something warm and familiar points you one way; a craving for something bright and fresh points you another. Instead of crowning a single winner, it helps to look at a handful of pies that cover the range, so you can match the pizza to the moment. At Brooklyn Pizza in central Boulder, a few blocks off the Pearl Street Mall, the menu is built around authentic New York-style pizza made from scratch. Here are three that are easy to recommend and what makes each one worth ordering.
How We Picked These Three
These are not picked by a popularity contest or a secret ranking. They are three pies that each do something well, and together they show the range of what a good New York-style kitchen can do. One is the everyday classic almost everyone enjoys; one keeps things simple and lets fresh ingredients shine; and one brings a bigger, saltier flavor for people who like a pizza with some attitude. What they share is the foundation: scratch-made dough crafted with premium flour, whole-milk mozzarella made in-house, and fresh vegetables delivered three times a week, not pulled from a can. Start with a base that’s good, and it is hard to go wrong, whichever of the three you choose.
Pepperoni, the New York Classic
If there is a default order in American pizza, it is pepperoni, and there is a reason it never goes out of style. On a thin, hand-stretched New York crust, the pepperoni crisps slightly at the edges while the whole-milk mozzarella melts into the sauce underneath. It is the pie that pleases a mixed group, satisfies a hungry kid, and still hits the spot after a long day on the trails. Pepperoni also happens to travel well, which makes it one of the smarter picks if you are taking it home instead of eating in. The flavor and texture hold up in the box far better than heavier, wetter toppings, so your first bite at home tastes close to the way it did coming out of the oven. For more picks that travel well, see which pizza is best to order online. For a first visit, or for a night when you just want something dependable, this is the one to beat.
Pizza Margarita, Simple Done Right
The Pizza Margarita is where a kitchen’s ingredients have nowhere to hide. With just tomato, mozzarella, and fresh basil carrying the whole pie, every part has to be good, and that is exactly why it is such a satisfying order at a scratch-made spot. The sauce tastes like real tomatoes, the cheese is made in-house, and the basil keeps the whole thing bright. It is lighter than a loaded specialty pie, which makes it a great choice when you want pizza without feeling weighed down, and it pairs beautifully with a crisp salad on the side. If you like a little more green and a peppery bite, Brooklyn Pizza also offers a Margarita with Arugula, which piles fresh arugula on top for an extra layer of flavor. Either version is a smart pick for anyone who believes the best food is often the simplest. Want the full story on the classic? See what kind of pizza a Margherita is.
Pizza Puttanesca, for the Bold Palate
For eaters who want their pizza to make a statement, the Pizza Puttanesca is the one to reach for. Puttanesca is a classic southern Italian preparation built around big, savory, briny flavors, traditionally olives, capers, anchovies, and garlic over a tomato base. It is salty, punchy, and deeply satisfying, the kind of pie that rewards an adventurous palate and pairs perfectly with a quiet night in. If bold and briny is your lane, this is the standout of the three. And if you love the idea but want to adjust it, the long topping list makes it easy to lean into the flavors you like most, whether that means extra olives, a handful of capers, or a little more garlic.Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza toppings at Brooklyn Pizza in Boulder?
Brooklyn Pizza offers a long list of fresh toppings, so favorites run the gamut. Classic choices like pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, and extra cheese are always in rotation, while toppings such as arugula, prosciutto, goat cheese, black olives, fresh tomatoes, and basil let you build something more adventurous. You can add them to a specialty pie or build your own in a 12-inch or 16-inch size.
Is New York-style pizza thin crust or thick crust?
New York-style pizza has a thin, hand-stretched crust that is crisp on the bottom and foldable by the slice. It is sturdier than it looks, which is why it holds its structure well in a to-go box. Brooklyn Pizza makes its New York-style dough from scratch with premium flour.
What is a Pizza Puttanesca?
Pizza Puttanesca is a bold, savory pizza inspired by a classic southern Italian sauce. It is traditionally built around briny, punchy ingredients like olives, capers, anchovies, and garlic over a tomato base, which gives it a salty, deeply flavorful bite. It is a favorite among people who like their pizza with a little attitude.
Which Brooklyn Pizza pie is best for a first visit?
If it is your first order, a classic is a safe and satisfying bet. The Pepperoni is the all-around crowd-pleaser, while the Pizza Margarita is a great pick if you prefer something lighter and fresher. Both show off the scratch-made dough and in-house mozzarella that define the kitchen.
Can I get a pizza made with fresh mozzarella in Boulder?
Yes. Every pie except the vegan option is topped with whole-milk mozzarella that Brooklyn Pizza makes in-house, and fresh mozzarella is also available as a topping if you want even more. It is a big part of why the pizzas taste the way they do.
How far in advance should I order pizza for a party in Boulder?
For large gatherings, it is best to call ahead. Brooklyn Pizza can handle catering orders of ten pizzas or more with advance notice, so the earlier you plan, the smoother it goes. For everyday orders, ordering a little early on busy Friday and Saturday nights helps your order be ready on time.
What the Top Pizzas Have in Common
Notice that all three come back to the same thing: quality you can taste in every bite. The crust is the part people underrate, and a scratch-made New York dough gives these pies their signature chew and crisp. The whole-milk mozzarella is made in the shop, not bought in bulk, and the vegetables are delivered fresh three times a week, so nothing tastes tired or frozen. Brooklyn Pizza has been doing this in Boulder since 2015, and that consistency is a big part of why it comes up when locals talk about where to eat in Boulder, and why regulars keep a short list of favorites and order them again and again. When the base is this solid, choosing a “top” pizza becomes less about avoiding a bad one and more about picking the flavor you are in the mood for.
Prefer to Build Your Own?
If none of the three is calling your name, the best pizza in Boulder might be the one you design yourself. Brooklyn Pizza lets you build your own pie in a 12-inch or 16-inch size from a long list of fresh toppings. Not sure how much to order? Check how many slices come in a large pizza. You can go classic with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, and extra cheese, or get creative with prosciutto, arugula, goat cheese, gorgonzola, garlic, black olives, fresh tomatoes, and basil. Eating plant-based? A vegan cheese option lets you build a fully plant-based pizza without giving up the pie. Pair whatever you create with a Caprese or Caesar salad and a couple of homemade cannolis, and you have a full meal.
How to Order in Boulder
Ready to try one of the top three, or build your own? You can order online for pickup, or call to place your order over the phone. Pickup gets your pizza into your hands at its freshest, moments after it leaves the oven, and ordering ahead on busy nights keeps the wait short.
Planning something bigger? Brooklyn Pizza handles catering orders of ten pizzas or more with advance notice, so a party, team dinner, or office lunch is easy to pull off. Still deciding what to get? Take your time with the menu, and if you are bringing a crowd, plan ahead. However you order, you are getting a scratch-made New York-style pie from one of Boulder’s go-to pizzerias. Questions about the menu or a custom order? Reach out any time at 720-328-2324.