Special Hours: From November 21 to 28 we’ll be opening at 11am

Last Updated: November 5, 2026

In this guide:

 

New York style pizza is a large round pie with a thin crust, tomato sauce and mozzarella, sold by the slice and folded to eat. In Boulder, CO, Brooklyn Pizza at 1647 Arapahoe Ave. has made it from scratch since 2015, with whole-milk mozzarella made in-house, by the slice or as a whole pie.

Ask for a New York slice in Boulder and you are asking for something specific. Here is what the style means, where it came from, and what it looks like at Brooklyn Pizza.

What Is New York Style Pizza?

Brooklyn Pizza graphic of a pepperoni and pesto pizza with the question: What is New York style pizza in Boulder, CO?New York style pizza is a large, round pie with a thin crust, a layer of tomato sauce and mozzarella, cut into wide slices that you can fold in half. It is built around the slice: one big piece you can hold in one hand at a counter or on the sidewalk.

The fold is the giveaway. A well-made slice bends without cracking, and the tip holds up instead of drooping.

The crust does two jobs. It is crisp enough to keep its shape and chewy enough to bite into.

Where Did New York Style Pizza Come From?

Britannica says Italian immigrants first made pizzas in their homes and sold them in unlicensed venues before Lombardi’s became the first licensed pizzeria in 1905, in New York. Saveur describes Lombardi’s pies as an Italian-American take on the Neapolitan original: larger in size and cooked in a coal oven.

The 1905 date is the traditional story, and it is not settled. A 2019 Smithsonian magazine report says researcher Peter Regas found newspaper evidence of pizza being sold in New York before Lombardi’s opened, and could not track down the 1905 license itself.

How Did the Slice Take Over?

Britannica says the pizza slice came with those early American pizzerias. It let busy workers buy a single serving to eat on the go instead of buying an entire pie.

That is still the idea behind a New York slice. It is quick to order and easy to eat standing up.

How Is New York Style Different From Neapolitan Pizza?

They share Italian roots and do different jobs. Neapolitan pizza is the original, and New York style grew from it into a larger pie that is cut up and shared, or sold by the slice.

That job explains the crust. A slice has to hold together in one hand, so the dough needs enough structure to stay flat when you pick it up. For a wider view of the city, see what is the best pizza in Boulder.

What New York Style Pizza Looks Like at Brooklyn Pizza

A plain cheese New York-style pizza on a wooden pizza peel

Brooklyn Pizza has served New York-style pizza on Arapahoe Ave. since 2015, by the slice and by the pie. The dough is scratch-made with premium flour, and the whole-milk mozzarella is made in-house and goes on every pie except the vegan one. Vegetables are delivered three times a week, so you will not find canned or frozen ones here. It also comes up on lists of where locals eat in Boulder.

The menu starts with the classics, plain cheese and pepperoni, and moves on to Italian Sausage and Rabe or Prosciutto and Arugula. Whole pies come in a 12-inch small or a 16-inch large, and vegan cheese is available. If you plan to take it home, see which pizza is best to order online.

Feeding a group? Our guide to how many slices come in a large pizza helps you plan. You can read the full story behind the dough, cheese and vegetables too.

How to Order New York Style Pizza in Boulder

The fastest route is to order online for pickup, or stop in at 1647 Arapahoe Ave., Boulder, CO 80302. You can also call 720-328-2324 to place an order.

Not sure what to try first? Our picks for the top 3 pizzas in Boulder walk through the menu.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is New York style pizza?

It is a large, round pie with a thin crust, tomato sauce and mozzarella, cut into wide slices that fold in half. It is closely tied to the pizza slice, which Britannica says came with early American pizzerias in New York.

What is the difference between a New York style pizza and a regular pizza?

There is no single regular pizza, because styles vary from Neapolitan to deep dish. New York style is the one built around large pies and foldable slices, and Saveur traces it to the Neapolitan original.

What is NY style pizza called?

It is usually just called New York style or NY style pizza. A single wide piece of it is a New York slice.

Is there New York style pizza in Boulder, CO?

Yes. Brooklyn Pizza at 1647 Arapahoe Ave. serves New York-style pizza by the slice and by the pie, and has done so since 2015.

Does Brooklyn Pizza sell pizza by the slice?

Yes. The restaurant serves pizza by the slice as well as by the pie, and whole pies come in a 12-inch small or a 16-inch large.

Does Brooklyn Pizza have vegan pizza?

Yes. Vegan cheese is available, and the whole-milk mozzarella that goes on every other pie is left off the vegan pizza. If you have allergies or dietary restrictions, tell the restaurant when you order.

Come Taste a New York Slice in Boulder

Skip the guesswork and try it yourself. Order ahead with the link above, or send us a message with questions about catering or dietary needs.