Last Updated: November 9, 2026
In this guide:
- The Best Pizzas to Order Online, by What You Are Craving
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What Makes a Pizza Worth Ordering Online
- How to Order Online for Pickup in Boulder
- Tips for the Best Online Pizza Order
The best pizza to order online in Boulder really depends on what you are craving, but a few choices rarely disappoint. Classic New York-style cheese and pepperoni travel well and please a crowd, while specialty pies like the Pizza Margarita, Pizza Pesto, and Four Cheese deliver bigger flavor, and a build-your-own on a 12-inch or 16-inch crust lets you get exactly what you want. At Brooklyn Pizza Boulder, you can order any of them online for pickup or phone in your order.
Ordering pizza online has become the default for busy weeknights, game days, and late-night cravings in Boulder. The hard part is not finding a place to order from; it is deciding what to actually put in your cart. The pizza that is best to order online is the one that matches your craving, feeds everyone at the table, and still tastes great by the time you get it home. Here is how to choose and what to look for when you order from a scratch-made kitchen like Brooklyn Pizza Boulder.
The Best Pizzas to Order Online, by What You Are Craving
There is no single winner here, so match the pizza to the moment. Here are the categories most people order from, and some standout options in each.
Classic Crowd-Pleasers
When you are feeding a group, a mix of ages, or you simply want something dependable, the classics are your friend. A straightforward cheese pizza is the easiest order to please everyone, from picky kids to anyone who just wants a clean, cheesy slice. Pepperoni is the natural next step, and it happens to be one of the better pizzas to take home because pepperoni keeps its flavor and texture well in the box. Both are simple, familiar, and hard to get wrong, which is exactly what you want when the table is counting on you.
Specialty Pies for Bigger Flavor
If you are ordering for yourself or a group that likes to branch out, the specialty pizzas are where the Brooklyn Pizza menu gets interesting. The Pizza Margarita keeps things bright and simple, and a Margarita with Arugula adds a fresh, peppery layer on top. The Pizza Pesto brings a rich, herbaceous base for anyone who wants something beyond red sauce, and the Four Cheese is an easy pick for serious cheese lovers. For bolder, saltier notes, the Pizza Puttanesca delivers, while heartier appetites can reach for the Homemade Sausage and Green Pepper, the Italian Sausage and Rabe, or the Prosciutto and Arugula. Ham and Mushroom, Bacon, Mushroom and Olive, and Spinach and Mushroom round out a lineup with something for just about every craving. Wondering which three pies lead the pack? See the top three pizzas in Boulder.
Veggie and Vegan Choices
Boulder eats a lot of plants, and the menu has options. You can build a fully vegetable pie from a long list of fresh toppings or start with a ready-made choice like the Spinach and Mushroom. For a fully plant-based order, Brooklyn Pizza offers a vegan cheese option, so you can skip the dairy without skipping the pizza. Pairing a pie with a fresh salad is an easy way to round out a vegetable-forward order.
Build Your Own
Sometimes the best pizza to order online is the one you design yourself. Brooklyn Pizza lets you build your own pie in a 12-inch or 16-inch size and top it however you like. The topping list runs long, from pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, and prosciutto to mushrooms, spinach, fresh onions, garlic, black olives, basil, fresh tomatoes, goat cheese, and more. If you have a go-to combination, this is the order that gets it exactly right every time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza to order online in Boulder, CO?
There is no single best pizza for everyone; it comes down to your craving. For a reliable choice that travels well, a classic New York-style cheese or pepperoni is hard to beat. If you want bolder flavor, specialty pies like the Pizza Margarita, Pizza Pesto, or Four Cheese are great options, and you can always build your own on a 12-inch or 16-inch crust at Brooklyn Pizza Boulder.
Which pizzas hold up best for takeout?
New York-style pizza travels well thanks to its thin, sturdy crust, and pies with drier toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and fresh vegetables tend to keep their texture better in the box than very wet ingredients. If you want your pizza at its absolute freshest, pickup lets you grab it moments after it leaves the oven.
How do you order Brooklyn Pizza online for pickup?
You can browse the menu on the Brooklyn Pizza website, add your pizza and any sides to your cart, and choose pickup at checkout, or call to order over the phone. Ordering ahead on busy Friday and Saturday nights helps your order be ready when you want it.
What sizes do Brooklyn Pizza’s pizzas come in?
Pizzas come in two sizes, a 12-inch and a 16-inch, so you can order the right amount whether you are feeding just yourself or a larger group.
Can you build your own pizza when you order online?
Yes. You can build your own pizza in a 12-inch or 16-inch size and add from a long list of fresh toppings, including pepperoni, prosciutto, arugula, goat cheese, mushrooms, basil, and more, right from the online menu.
Can you order a vegan pizza online from Brooklyn Pizza?
Yes. Brooklyn Pizza offers a vegan cheese option, so you can build a fully plant-based pizza from the fresh vegetable toppings and order it online for pickup. Fresh salads are also available to round out the meal.
What Makes a Pizza Worth Ordering Online
Eating a pizza fresh from the oven in a dining room is one thing. Ordering it online for pickup is a little different, because the pie has to survive a short trip home before you take your first bite. A few things make certain pizzas better suited to that trip.
New York-style pizza is a strong starting point. Its thin, sturdy crust holds its structure in the box, reheats cleanly in a hot oven, and does not turn to mush the way thicker, heavily loaded styles sometimes can. Scratch-made dough and quality cheese matter too, because a well-made pie still tastes good a few minutes after it leaves the kitchen. Brooklyn Pizza works with scratch-made dough and whole-milk mozzarella made in-house, which gives its pizzas the kind of structure that travels.
Toppings play a role as well. Drier toppings like pepperoni, sausage, and fresh vegetables tend to hold up better in transit than very wet ingredients. If your pickup means a longer drive home, leaning toward those sturdier toppings helps keep your pizza closer to its just-baked best.
How to Order Online for Pickup in Boulder
Ordering is simple. You can browse the full menu online, add what you want to your cart, and order online for pickup, or call to place your order over the phone. Pickup is a great option if you are close by and want your pizza at its freshest, since you can grab it moments after it leaves the oven. Ordering ahead on busy evenings and weekends helps your order be ready when you want it. The kitchen also stays open late on Friday and Saturday, until midnight, which makes it an easy call after a game, a show, or a long day outside. It is also a regular stop on the list of where locals eat in Boulder.
Tips for the Best Online Pizza Order
A few small moves make any online pizza order better. Order a little earlier than you think you need to on Friday and Saturday nights, when kitchens everywhere are busiest. If you are reheating later, a hot oven or a skillet will revive a slice far better than a microwave, which tends to soften the crust. Think about the whole meal while you are at it; adding a fresh salad or finishing with a couple of cannolis turns a quick pizza order into a full dinner. And if you are ordering for a group, pairing one classic pie with one specialty pie is a reliable way to keep everyone happy, and this guide to how many slices are in a large pizza helps you size the order.
So, which pizza is best to order online in Boulder? The honest answer is the one that fits your craving and your crowd. Go classic when you want dependable, go specialty when you want to branch out, and build your own when you know exactly what you want. For a wider look at the whole city, read what makes the best pizza in Boulder. Browse the full menu, place your order online for pickup, or get in touch and call 720-328-2324 to order from Brooklyn Pizza Boulder today.